Dissertation Reviewer Comments Text

Jonathan Friesen - Writing Coach

The foremost advantage of a peer is that you have an experienced doctorate, guiding you about the essentials of a dissertation and the vital areas that must be given the needed attention. When your dissertation enters our peer review process, it significantly gets rid of the fear of rejection by the review committee. The peer review experts assess your work in detail and provide inputs for improvement in all chapters, which once corrected will ensure that your work is near to approval. Peer review includes editing and hence you will not need to opt for proofreading or editing services if you opt for peer review service.

Analytical Phd Thesis

The following are testimonials from dissertation reviews participants and readers. Having my dissertation reviewed by someone external to my committee members was a great experience. His comments will be going to be of great help in the process of turning my dissertation on a book manuscript. I have as well been able to showcase my work and added it to my own website and to my job applications.

Cristián doña reveco, visiting assistant professor, michigan state university i want to express my deep appreciation to my reviewer, dr pierre fuller, lecturer in east asian history, university of manchester, and editor in chief dissertation reviews, dr. Pierre took his time to read my work carefully and provided me with thoughtful, detailed feedback. Constructive criticism from an informed reader who is not too familiar with my work is particularly helpful in the process of revising my dissertation into a book manuscript. I am grateful for dissertation reviews to offer such an inspiring and productive forum for junior scholars. Qian zhu, bkt assistant professor in history and modern languages, wabash college i would like to express my heartfelt appreciation and gratitude to jovan maud, lecturer at institute for social and cultural anthropology, georg august university, göttingen, germany for his insightful comments and generous review of my dissertation. He has helped to clarify and articulate elegantly the approach, themes and issues which i have sought to address in my dissertation.

Jovans careful and meticulous review has given me tremendous encouragement as an early scholar in the field. I am thankful for the great work that dissertation reviews is putting in and i am sure that it will continue to be a valuable form of intellectual support for many more scholars to come. Arthur chia, postdoctoral fellow, massachusetts institute of technology through and through, the process with dissertation reviews was professional and timely, and im thrilled to have participated. Having dylan lotts professional and attentive review has given me a new way to think about my own research, as well as share it with others.

The review will be invaluable when i transition the dissertation to a manuscript. Im thrilled to know about this site, and to be able to pass the word along to others. David citrin, affiliate instructor, university of washington the dissertation reviews program provides a much needed space for junior researchers to showcase their work, and receive constructive feedback from top members of their fields. I am so grateful for elizabeth fein’s in depth, unbiased review of my dissertation. Fein’s careful, detailed breakdown of my work allows me to finally see its strengths and weaknesses.

As i attempt to reorganize and edit portions of my dissertation for a book manuscript, her comments are an invaluable guide in allowing me to step outside myself, and locate my research in the wider context of the field of medical anthropology. I recommend the dissertationreviews.org process to anyone seeking an honest, outside review of their dissertation, and anyone interested in exploring emerging scholarship from junior scholars. Jennifer taylor, lecturer, academy of art university i am very grateful to the team at dissertation reviews for putting these valuable profiles of recent scholarship at our fingertips and for creating a forum for rich intellectual exchange. I am especially thankful to jennifer bright, who reviewed my dissertation in tibetan studies. Offering astute and helpful feedback that will be useful as i turn the dissertation into a book, and to nicole willock who facilitated the review. Willa miller, visiting lecturer, harvard university dissertation reviews has provided a wonderful platform for me to engage with other scholars about my work.

Ive always wanted to meet my reviewer ive read her work and followed her for many years, but i never had the courage to contact her myself. Dissertation reviews provided me with the forum to ask for her advice and help, which i consider an invaluable step forward in the process of revising the manuscript. While writing my dissertation, i was under a clock, and also extremely close to my sources and materials. My reviewer has helped me to step back to think about the field more broadly, and done so in a kind and generous way.

Its also helped other scholars even my friends, who know me in a social context to understand what ive been doing. I know that i often go to dissertation reviews to learn about other peoples work, especially in fields that are less familiar to me. Perhaps i would have found out about dissertation reviews on facebook, but i have had the pleasure of meeting tom mullaney in person. He offers the thoughtful, insightful, gentle but incisive feedback that he promotes on dissertation reviews. Im grateful for his service, which i think helps transition graduate students into professionals. Finally, my thanks and admiration for cropping the image just right! i adore that image, and they did a great job of presenting it in an aesthetically pleasing way. Margaret tillman, visiting assistant professor, university of mississippi associate professor at hokkaido university emma cooks thoughtful comments on my dissertation have been immensely helpful during the process of turning the thesis into a book manuscript.

Columbia University Department of Economics Discussion Paper Series

Since i was already working on revising my dissertation it was a great opportunity to have somebody else read it and give such thoughtful feedback. Her insightful and constructive comments have informed the revisions of my thesis and i am thankful that dissertation reviews provides the platform for this exchange of ideas. April yoder made a thorough and deep reading of my work and offered constructive and encouraging comments/suggestions. As a junior faculty member, with all the pressures of tenure, receiving such positive critique and friendly suggestions for improvements is really needed and appreciated. Her comments and suggestions come at the right time as i try to turn part of the dissertation into a book.

Essay on Urban Life Today