Critical Review of Newspaper Article Text

Jonathan Friesen - Writing Coach

Analysis of a newspaper article: analyzing a newspaper or magazine article requires specific skills which few students acquire without being deliberately taught and practiced. The example/project suggested below may be adapted for any history or social studies curriculum law, sociology, civics, political science, economics.

    to teach students to identify the main idea of article, the reason for it being written.
to use a specific newspaper article to show students how to analyze and examine different viewpoints in news articles. questions for analyzing the article: a. Does the author provide enough factual material to support his ideas quotes witnesses, provides statistics, states his sources of information? was he an eyewitness to events or was the information obtained through a news service? e. Are different viewpoints presented? is this article an editorial author rsquo s own ideas , is it informative, is it convincing, is it balanced? g.
    using michael ceren rsquo s article in the saturday sun, november 18, 20, ldquo the forgotten holocaust rdquo .

    According to coren, what was the number of ukrainians who were starved to death, c. What is coren rsquo s attitude towards the deniers of the genocide and why ? using ian hunter rsquo s article. ldquo a tale of truth and two journalists rdquo , march 27, 20 in report magazine. w.infoukes.com/genocide/hunter01.htm 1. What explanation is given for the discrepancies between the two journalists? who told the truth? 3.

    Write a short expose on how you feel about duranty and his pulitzer prize for journalism? 1. Why does margolis feel that recognition of the ukrainian genocide is long overdue? 0116828 a critical review of newspaper articles published in october 2003, 'after' the war in iraq for the purpose of this review i have chosen to discuss three separate newspaper articles regarding the war in iraq. Firstly, i chose an article from 'the observer', entitled 'free after 50 years of tyranny', written by julie flint at the beginning of october, 2003. This article was written shortly after the united states us and britain declared victory for the west, but there was still much controversy regarding the legitimacy of partaking in the war. Flint dismisses britain's fears of going to war, indicating the end result has justified the efforts we put forward, and depicts anti war activists as ignorant 'the anti war lobby has refused to listen to those iraqis who supported war over continued tyranny.' flint, 2003 she praises 'the brits' and tends to blame us troops for any mistakes that were made. She claims that 'western reporters detail, quite properly, the misdeeds, the crimes even, of the occupying forces.

    Crime And Punishment Dostoevsky Essay Topics

    But this is only part of the story.' flint, 2003 the second article, 'pentagon was warned of iraq chaos after war', was written from new york, by david teather and was published on october 20th 2003 in 'the guardian'. This article discusses a report, which was allegedly released to the pentagon and us officials before the war, which warned of the danger in invading iraq in relation to the reconstruction of the country. However, there are further determinants in the diversity of reports on post war iraq.

    Essay About Slave Life

    Ettema, 1997: 44 , states 'journalists live and work within an encompassing social and cultural context that powerfully and implicitly informs their attempts to make sense of the world. Journalists have no alternative but to draw upon intellectual tools theory and concept, myth and metaphor of their place and time in the world.' for example, if these events had been reported in an alternative country's media, they would have been reported very differently. This can be seen in the critical references to the us as an agent in the war, as opposed to britain, 'critics who argue that the us government has mismanaged the situation.'. 'the content of the news media inevitably reflects the interests of those who pay the bills. The argument, in other words, is that the financiers or the paymasters, as we can call them or the group they represent will not allow their media to publish material that frustrates their vital interests.' altschull, 1997: 259 this possibility of bias must be taken into account when critically analysing any piece of media, but is difficult to establish as the investors are not obviously publicised. In conclusion, i believe that although these articles provide different accounts of opinions post war, they all have an underlying meaning, which is the intended unification of british public, in one form or another. The broadsheets intend to restore confidence in the government, by blaming the us for leading us to, and mistakes in, the war, and by insisting that the efforts provided by the british soldiers were indeed worthwhile.

    The tabloid, however, aims at creating a unified remembrance for the human element in the war, an element that will touch all groups within society, so appeals to the wider reader. The diversity within these articles is inevitable, as different peoples accounts will always vary, as opinions do, and this cannot be ruled out for journalists. Other forms of bias within the articles can be associated with the financial supporters, the editor of the paper 0116828 and their individual views and the intended audience of the paper. All of these factors must be considered when analysing any media piece, in order to understand the intended meaning.

    The above preview is unformatted text analysis of a newspaper article assignment newspaper and magazine articles are used as a source of information to the public for all sorts of things including medical information. Many times they report statistical information or results without explaining the methods used to come to their conclusions. However, the focus on npd has evolved over the years, from having an internal company view to external market view. The article titled, customer support and new product development goffin amp new, 2001 , takes us a step further in the approach to npd. The critical review paper is not meant to be a difficult or onerous assignment. In this short paper i want you to critically analyze and interpret a research article that is relevant to the study of navigation. In many respects you can consider this assignment as nothing more than a book review , which practically everyone has had to write at one time or another.

    Block Style Argumentative Essay

    The only difference is that in this case you are not reviewing an entire book, but only a single journal article. First, it will expose you to the process of critically reading a scientific journal article. Journal articles are the primary means by which scientists communicate with one another. If you continue on in the sciences you will spend a great deal of time reading journal articles. It sounds cliche, but the sooner you start reading journal articles with an eye towards considering the validity of the authors' conclusions, the easier and more productive it will be in the long run. Incidently, even if you are not planning on continuing in the sciences, the ability to evaluate a journal article critically is of great use.

    While the majority of scientists do not purposefully attempt to dupe the public, occassionally errors are made in research. More often other people generally those without a background in science incorrectly interpret or paraphrase a researcher's work. If you know how to read a scientific paper critically you can go directly to the source and determine for yourself the accuracy of a statement. The second purpose of this assignment is to give you, the student, an opportunity to practice your writing skills and to get feedback from me prior to handing in your major research paper assignmemt.